Did you read my post about our Christmas tree yesterday? Did you see the picture of the tree?
I have to admit, it's not real. We went fake last year. But it does look real--at least we think so. It was a tough decision, not done in haste. We shopped around groping trees in all the stores till we found one that felt and looked life-like.
There were a number of reasons we went fake.
- We have a wood stove and it's too hard to keep tree watered and 'living' from Thanksgiving till Christmas. It's just so sad to watch the tree die before your eyes!
- Since the trees dry out so quickly, the needles get EVERYWHERE! You just can't vacuum them all up and they get tracked throughout the house. By Christmas you end up with a Charlie Brown tree.
- A dry tree is a wicked fire hazard. We love our family too much to lose them in a fire.
- We found that our allergies got bad during the time it was up in our living room each year. Instead we burn a pine scented candle.
- We feel bad being responsible for the death of a tree each year.
- The trees are costing more each year! So each year our tree was having to get shorter just to stay within the family budget. Which meant fewer of our ornaments could fit on it!
- Instead we spend the money each year on trees to plant on our two acres! This year we planted to Spreading Poplars for about the same price as a Christmas tree! (Plus that's two more oxygen producing trees! Our part in reducing the carbon dioxide that we produce and to lowering the temperature in our backyard during the summer! Our part to fight global warming too!)
I was feeling really good about our decision until I read the article on MSN today: Is a fake Christmas tree the Green Choice?
This is one of the problems they explain with plastic trees:
"The problem with plastic
If you're thinking you're keeping a tree alive by hanging on to an artificial tree for nine or 10 years, don't pat yourself on the back just yet. Once you're sick of the plastic tree, Chastagner says, it'll live on in a landfill for centuries. Not eternal, perhaps, but from the American perspective, darned close.
Plastic trees also can cause more-immediate health problems. After just a week indoors, many artificial trees shed a dry dust containing lead, a powerful neurotoxin, the University of North Carolina's late environmental studies director, Richard Maas, found in his research
"It would still in many usage scenarios expose a young child to enough lead to knock a couple of IQ points off that child's intellectual ability," Maas told WSBTV in Atlanta in 2005."
I'm starting to believe that everything contains lead! If that's the case of everything that comes from Asia, how come China is known for its overpopulation problems? Are they immune to the lead or do they just send it all over to the U.S? Are the Asian countries trying to dumb us down?
The article also says that most people don't go out to a forest and cut down their own tree. The living trees come from tree farms and...
In fact, the market for Christmas trees means millions are planted each year, each "sequestering" by expert estimates, anywhere from 40 to 300 pounds of carbon dioxide a year.
So, by buying a real tree, you're saving the Earth, just a little, as well as sustaining what many would call the green heart and soul of Christmas. "They were originally put up to show life in the dead of winter," says Patrick Downey, a Christmas-tree grower in Sherbrooke, Quebec. "Putting up a plastic tree has no meaning whatsoever."
So now did we make a good decision? Or are we compensating enough by planting trees each year. We promise to use the tree till it falls apart! And we're sure to sell it at a garage sale if we ever get rid of it! You can count on that!
Being green sure is difficult!